Reply To: Contributor Users can Add but only Edit sometimes

@ Sam

Well, the first thing I see, is you should assigned either Add Entry or Add Entry Moderated, not both.

After some quick testing… you also need to add the View List (Manage) capability too. That not entirely intuitive, but that edit link when Form is not installed/active would go to the admin page instead. Form changes the link destination, but still has to pass the same capability checks. Technically if they knew the exact admin page URL they could get to and view the mage admin page even though the link is hidden because they do not have the View Admin Menu capability but there is not anything that can’t already do in the frontend with Form (less actually) so I don’t really see that as an issue.

Any way, hope that helps!