Steven Zahm@ Reba
This was definitely a bug with the Reviews extension for Connections. When I disabled the plugin the pagination worked as expected.
I did locate and fix the bug in the extension. This is a bit technical… please bare with me. The reviews are stored as a custom post type within WordPress. This in an excellent way to handle saving reviews. Now, to show those reviews for each entry, you need to query that custom post type to retrieve all the reviews that have been submitted for each entry. Doing a custom query alters the initial main query that WordPress made to originally show the page. The pagination and many other items in core Connections relies on the data from the initial main query. Now, the fix was as simple as resetting WordPress back to the initial main query by adding wp_reset_query(); after the reviews for each entry is shown.