[Steven Zahm]

@ Rick

I had to read this a couple times … this is not a bug and defaulting to private when login is required is not going to happen; here’s why …

I easily see how this can seem redundant … but there many people using this feature. By selecting the login required, you redefine who the public is. Public becomes those that are assigned the “Subscriber” role and private is “Author” and “Editor” by default.