Steven Zahm@ Reed
Ha, funny! I am sooo used to getting confirming emails I guess I completely missed that I can simply log in.
That said…
I did log in and see the issue. Something is very, very, wrong with the theme. Locking at the page source…
The page should end with:
</body>
</html>
But yours does not. It goes on to show the </article><!-- #post --> and then some HTML for the comments then just stops. This is very broken HTML. The browsers must simply stop rendering the page when they come to the </html> tag. However, that closing </article> is missing up in the body where it should be.
Those issues aside, my previous reply where I mentioned the possibility of the missing wp_footer() template tag, I suspect this is the reason Form does not work correctly. This infact will break a lot of plugins.
I suggest getting the theme fixed and ensure the wp_footer() template tag exists in the footer.php file (if the theme has one).
Hope that helps!